Search recipe:

Grandma Gertie's Pumpkin Pie
  • 1 9-inch Pie Crust
  • 1/3 large can of Pumpkin
  • 5 Hickman large egg yolks
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1 tsp pumpkin pie spice
  • 1 tblsp vanilla
  • 1 1/2 cans evaporated milk
Directions
In large mixing bowl, mix sugar and spice together, set aside. In mixer bowl, blend egg yolks one at a time into pumpkin, then add milk, sugar/spice, and vanilla on low. Pour mixture into 9-inch pie shell and bake at 350 degrees until filling sets, 35-40+ minutes depending on oven. Brett Hickman suggests topping it with a mountain of whip cream!!! Source: Hickman Family Farms …
Provided by:
Brett Hickman, Hickman's Family Farms

Where You Can Buy Ingredients:

Farmers
47 Ranch Sky Island Beef

McNeal, Arizona, 85617
View details
A Bar H Farm

Anya Owens and Josh Koehn

San Simon, AZ, 85632
View details
Abraham's Faith Garden

Concho, Arizona, 85924
View details
Adams Family Farms

Wayne Adams

Dewey, AZ, 86327
View details
Agua Linda Farm

Laurel Loew

Amado, AZ, 85645
View details
Apple Annies

Annie Holcomb

Willcox, AZ, 85643
View details
Bathtub Spring Farm

Gary & Marilyn Hart

Nutrioso, AZ, 85932
View details
Buckelew Farm Pumpkin Festival & Corn Maze

Clint Buckelew

Tucson, AZ, 85735
View details
Chile Acres

Jimmie & Celia Peterson

Tonopah, Arizona, 85354
View details
Collier Farm

Rhonda Collier

Chino Valley, AZ, 86323
View details
Crow's Dairy, Inc

Wendell & Rhonda Crow - Mary Lou & Erik Hernandez

Buckeye, Arizona, 85326
View details
Double Blessings

Kathryn Marshall

Apache Junction, AZ, 85119
View details
Hickman's Family Farms

Sharman Hickman

Buckeye, Arizona, 85326
View details
Hopkins Hog Farm

Elija Hopkins

Aguila, AZ, 85320
View details
JH Grass Fed

Cave Creek, Arizona, 85327
View details
La Buena Vida Farm

Jerry Racicot

Portal, Arizona, 85632
View details
Lewis' Hen House & Veggie Farm

Doug Henderson

, ,
View details
Lunt Bunch Pumpkins

Terrol & Kimberly Lunt

Duncan, AZ, 85534
View details
M Triangle Ranch

Mark & Shelley Michaels

Bonita, Arizona, 85643
View details
Moonrise Farms

Jimmy Videle & Lorraine Wiesen

Concho, AZ, 85294
View details
Mother Nature's Farm

Wade Kelsall

Gilbert, AZ, 85233-1542
View details
Patriot's Dream Farm

Tucson, Arizona, 85735
View details
San Ysidro Farm

Nathan and Jackie Watkins

McNeal, AZ, 85617
View details
Schnepf Farms

Carrie Schnepf

Queen Creek, AZ, 85242
View details
Sheep Springs Sheep Co dba Dobson Family Farm Inc.

Marc Pedersen

Chandler, AZ, 85248
View details
Sunflower Farms

Scottsdale, Arizona
View details
Superstition Farm

Casey Stechnij, Jason and Alison Crittenden

Mesa, AZ, 85212
View details
The Cotton Shedd, LLC

Rodney & Tiffany Shedd

Eloy, Arizona, 85131
View details
The Simple Farm

Michael and Lylah Ledner

Scottsdale, AZ, 85260
View details
Tolmachoff Farms

Bill & Grace Tolmachoff

Glendale, AZ, 85303
View details
Vertuccio Farms


View details

Related Videos:

Popular Ingredients:

All Ingredients